Physics · Middle school
Why is average speed not always the mean of two speeds?
A car travels 60 m at 6 m/s, then another 60 m at 3 m/s. The two speeds average to 4.5 m/s if you give them equal weight. Use the experiment’s trip timer to find out whether 4.5 m/s would actually get the car to the finish in the same time.
Add the times before dividing
The first 60 m takes 60 ÷ 6 = 10 s. The second takes 60 ÷ 3 = 20 s. Average speed is total distance divided by total elapsed time, giving 120 ÷ 30 = 4.00 m/s. The car spends twice as long at 3 m/s as it does at 6 m/s. An arithmetic mean of the two speeds would give each speed the same weight, which would be appropriate if the car spent equal times at those speeds.
Compare the two segments of the solid line in the experiment. In the first 10 s, the line rises by 60 m. In the next 20 s, it rises by another 60 m. The slope is therefore 6 m/s before the change and 3 m/s after it. The dashed comparison line goes from the start to the finish in the same total time, with a constant slope of 4.00 m/s.
A stop adds time without adding distance
Keep both speeds and set the halfway wait to 10 s. Move the time slider to around 15 s. The orange marker lies on the horizontal segment at 60.0 m. From 10 s to 20 s, the clock keeps going but the distance stays fixed, so the slope is zero.
The trip now takes 40 s and still covers 120 m. The average falls to 3.00 m/s. The slope of the last moving segment is also 3 m/s, but the quantities refer to different intervals. Try a 20 s stop. The trip average falls again to 2.40 m/s while the slope of the last moving segment stays the same.
Check your understanding
Set both legs to 6 m/s and make the car wait 10 s halfway. Predict the finish time, trip average speed and where the graph is horizontal.
Show the explanation
Each leg takes 10 s and the stop adds 10 s. The finish time is 30 s, and the average is 120 ÷ 30 = 4.00 m/s. The graph stays at 60.0 m from 10 s to 20 s.
What the model assumes
Motion is straight and forward, with two fixed 60 m legs at constant speeds and an optional halfway stop. The model ignores acceleration and braking. The graph shows distance travelled, including the zero increase while waiting. The interactive experiment requires Family Plus or Teacher access.